Most homeowners looking for a plumber, painter, or electrician end up on a marketplace where independent contractors bid for the job. The platform feels like the easy option. But there's a meaningful difference between hiring an individual contractor through a marketplace and hiring a company that employs its own crews. Here's why that difference matters.
Who is actually responsible for the work?
When you hire an independent contractor through a marketplace like Angi, Thumbtack, or TaskRabbit, the contractor is responsible — not the platform. If the work is poor, you're negotiating with a sole proprietor or small business, not a company with a customer service department and a guarantee. When you hire a company like Novum that employs its own crews, the company is on the hook for the result, and you have a clear, single point of contact.
Insurance and liability
Independent contractors are supposed to carry their own general liability and workers' compensation insurance. In practice, solo operators sometimes let policies lapse, carry inadequate coverage, or don't have workers' comp at all. If a contractor is injured on your property without workers' comp, you could be liable. A company that employs its own crews carries insurance for all of its workers — no gaps.
- ✓Independent contractor: carries own insurance (coverage varies, may lapse)
- ✓Company employee: covered under the employer's policy — no liability gap
Consistent quality standards
Independent contractors set their own quality standards. Even within a single marketplace, the person doing a plumbing job on Monday and a different contractor doing it on Friday have different habits, tools, and skill levels. A company that employs its crews can enforce consistent training, use approved tools and products, and follow company quality standards on every job.
What happens when something goes wrong
With an independent contractor, a dispute typically means phone calls, texts, and eventually small claims court if they don't return. With a company that employs its crews, there's a clear escalation path. You call the company, they dispatch someone to correct the issue, and the work is guaranteed. This is why companies like Novum can offer a guarantee — they control the work, so they can stand behind it.
The real cost comparison
Independent contractors from marketplaces often appear cheaper upfront. But the full cost includes your time sorting bids, the risk premium of unguaranteed work, and the cost of correcting mistakes if something goes wrong. Flat-rate pricing from a company like Novum is often comparable to what you'd pay a marketplace contractor — with the added protection of a guarantee and consistent quality.
Bottom line
Hiring a company that employs its own crews isn't just about convenience. It's about accountability, consistent quality, and knowing who's responsible when something isn't right. The marketplace model transfers that risk to you; the direct employer model keeps it with the company.
Need handyman work done?
Novum sends its own licensed crew. Flat upfront quote before we touch anything.